Skip to content

Muslim Fish Hoagie

Philadelphia's great Muslim sandwich: marinated whiting fried, chopped on the griddle, bound with melted cheese into a honey whole-wheat roll, and piled with peppers, onion, pickle, and a sweet-tangy sauce the city calls Muslim sauce.

8 hr 20 min · Serves 4 · Medium

Recipe by Halal Gourmet Editorial Team

Serves
4

Ingredients

Fish

Assembly

Sauce

Time
Prep 480 min · Cook 20 min · 500 min total
Difficulty
medium
  1. 1

    Marinate the whiting overnight in the seasoning blend.

    480 min
  2. 2

    Dredge in flour and fry lightly — just enough to set the fish.

    8 min
  3. 3

    Move to a hot griddle and chop with a spatula; melt the cheese into the fish so it binds.

    7 min
  4. 4

    Pack into the roll with peppers, onion, pickle, tomato, and lettuce; finish with the sauce.

    5 min

Notes and swaps

Allergens
Not assessed yet. Check each ingredient if you have an allergy.

Community discussion

More to cook

Halal Cart & American Muslim

Baked Mac and Cheese

1 hr 10 min · Serves 10

Halal Cart & American Muslim

Dearborn-Style Shawarma Plate

4 hr 40 min · Serves 4

Halal Cart & American Muslim

Gullah Geechee Red Rice

1 hr 20 min · Serves 6

Halal Cart & American Muslim

Halal Cart Chicken & Rice

4 hr 40 min · Serves 4